Jack and Jill
Jack and Jill is a comedy film directed by Dennis Dugan, written by Steve Koren and Adam Sandler, and starring Sandler (in a dual role), alongside Al Pacino, Katie Holmes, and Eugenio Derbez.
Ad executive Jack Sadelstein has to both put up with the Thanksgiving visit from his twin sister Jill, and convince acting legend Al Pacino to do a Dunkin' Donuts commercial.
Why It Sucks
- The way Adam Sandler plays the two title characters is poorly done.
- The "identical twin" fact is completely wrong. Identical twins must be identical. If they are two different genders then they are fraternal twins, two completely different babies who happen to be born at the same time from the same mom.
- Ridiculous and laughable concept.
- Product placement everywhere, even being the focus of the story (e.g. Jack trying to get Al Pacino to advertise Dunkin' Donuts).
- Horrendous jokes.
- Both Jack and Jill are unlikable in their own different ways, especially Jill because she can be quite selfish and rather whiny sometimes. For example, when she complained and sulked because there was one birthday cake). Also, Jill's appearance is very ugly, and all you can see is Adam Sandler in drag.
- Terrible acting, save for Al Pacino.
- Lots of pointless celebrity cameos featuring Al Pacino, Drew Carey, Christie Brinkley, Johnny Depp, Vince Offer, etc. It also features a cameo from Jared Fogle, which did not age well.
- Jill's voice is ear-piercing and annoying.
- Cringeworthy dialogue.
- The Dunkaccino isn't a product made up for the movie, by the way. It's an actual product you can buy.
- The story is predictable and non-existent.
- Poor editing where a lot of scenes come out of nowhere.
- The Thanksgiving dinner scene would make sense if it took place at the end of the film instead.
- Felipe's grandmother, Juangelina, who was also played by Eugenio Derbez looks way too horrible, her voice is out of place and she's shown too much which makes her downright terrifying and nightmare inducing.
- So much padding.
- If Al Pacino changed his first name from "Al" to "Dunk", his full name would be "Dunk Pacino" not "Dunkaccino".
- The scene where Poopsie goes into the chocolate fountain caused internet wide controversy.
- Pop culture references in every single scene such as Cats And Dogs 3.
- The Mexican stereotypes are offensive.
- Jack's wife, Erin, is unlikable and bland, as she scolded Jack for yelling at Jill in the theater, even though Jill was in the wrong for answering her phone loudly.
- The film is bookended by interviews with real life sets of twins, which feels pretty genuine.
- It's much shorter than Just Go With It.
- Al Pacino's performance is the one part that movie critics agreed was good.
- The rap in the Dunkin' Donuts commercial at the end is meant to be bad, but for the viewers, it's pretty funny when you're not cringing.
- When Jill is shown in her teenage years, she was played by a young boy instead of a girl, so there is a hint of consistency.
- At the end of the film, after he's seen himself in the Dunkin' Donuts commercial, Al Pacino tells Jack to "burn this", which has led viewers to believe that he may have actually been talking about this film.
- Al Pacino pretending to go as somebody else at the Lakers game only for his identity to be revealed and was embarrassed was a bit funny.
Jack and Jill was universally panned by critics and audiences alike and is often considered to be one of the worst movies of all time. The film currently holds a 3% "rotten" rating on Rotten Tomatoes with an average of and a critic consensus that reads "Although it features an inexplicably committed performance from Al Pacino, Jack and Jill is impossible to recommend on any level whatsoever." Film critic Brett Michell of The Boston Phoenix awarded the film a zero out of five stars and described the film as "Unpleasant even by Sandler's usual standards, it's easily the star's worst film. And it co-stars Al Pacino. (It's his worst film, too.)" Ellen E. Jones of Total Film stated in her review "Sandler's brash, unpretentious and unsubtle family comedy might be more enjoyable if it wasn't so mean." Gary Thompson of Philadelphia Daily News stated "It feels a little lazy, like Dugan and Sandler didn't work hard enough to iron out the premise." Richard Roeper of the Chicago Sun-Times noted the irony of Pacino's presence, as the actor is best known for playing Michael Corleone in The Godfather, which is widely considered one of the best films ever made, in this film, which he called "one of the worst movies in the history of cinema!" Ramin Setoodeh of The Daily Beast and Peter Travers of Rolling Stone reviewed it together in an article entitled "Adam Sandler's Jack and Jill Is the Worst Movie Ever Made". After an hour-long critique, RedLetterMedia claimed that it was "so egregious that it ceased to be a film", and the site also later called it "the worst thing in the world". Mike McGranaghan wrote, on his website The Aisle Seat: "Howard the Duck, Gigli, Showgirls, From Justin to Kelly. What do they all have in common? They're all widely considered among the worst big studio movies ever made. You know what else they have in common? They're all better than Jack and Jill." Jack and Jill was featured in the top ten worst films of all time poll conducted by RiffTrax.
The film opened up at #2 on its opening weekend grossing $25,003,575. It would later make a total domestic gross of $74,158,157. In foreign markets, the film made $75,515,631. Overall, the film grossed $149,673,788 worldwide. The film was a box office disappointment.
Awards and nominations
Jack and Jill was nominated for twelve Golden Raspberry Awards and won all ten Golden Raspberry Awards including Worst Picture, Actor, Screenplay and was nominated for Worst Supporting Actress for David Spade (in drag). It became the first movie to sweep all the Razzies at the time, beating the record of the Razzies for I Know Who Killed Me, Battlefield Earth and Showgirls.